Shingles, Metal, or Tile? Choosing the Best Roofing Material for Your MO Home

Big Bear Roofing • March 5, 2025
A roofer working on a shingle.
A close up of a roof with the word roofing on the bottom

When it comes to selecting the right roofing material for your Missouri home, there are plenty of factors to consider – but at Big Bear Roofing we’ve already made one choice easy, your roofing contractor. The roofing needs of your home can vary based on size, aesthetic preference, cost, durability, and weather resistance, and we’re the professionals you want by your side no matter the type of roofing you need.


With Missouri’s unpredictable weather—ranging from heavy rain and hail to scorching (often humid) summers and freezing winters—it’s crucial to choose a roof that can withstand the elements while enhancing your home’s value and curb appeal. Whether metal, shingles, or tile, we’ve got you covered at Big Bear Roofing.


Whether you’re building a new home or upgrading the roof of your current home, call
Big Bear Roofing  at (314) 350-7378 for a professional recommendation on the best roofing options for your home. 


Asphalt Shingles: The Classic, Affordable Choice


Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in not only Missouri, but the United States as a whole – and it’s easy to see why! Known for their affordability, ease of installation, and versatility, shingles provide a reliable option for many homeowners.


Pros of Asphalt Shingles


Affordability – Asphalt shingles are one of the most budget-friendly roofing options, making them accessible for homeowners on any budget, including a tight one.
Versatility & Variety
– Shingles come in a wide range of colors and textures, allowing you to choose a classic option or create a signature stand-out look.
Weather Resistance
– Quality shingles can withstand moderate weather conditions, including rain and wind, and some brands offer impact-resistant options for hail-prone areas. Although they are not the most weather-resistant option, they protect homes well in most situations and are suited well for the weather in the St. Louis area.
Ease of Installation & Repairs
– Roofing professionals can install asphalt shingles quickly, and individual shingles can be replaced on their own so repairs can be done with little disruption to the roof as a whole.


Cons of Asphalt Shingles


Shorter Lifespan – Compared to metal and tile, asphalt shingles typically last 15-30 years (versus 40-70 years), depending on maintenance and weather exposure.
Susceptibility to Extreme Weather
  – Shingles can suffer damage from heavy winds, hail, and extreme heat, which can cause cracking or curling over time. Missouri occasionally experiences extreme weather, so shingles will likely occasionally need to be replaced on your St. Louis home.
Environmental Concerns
– Asphalt shingles are not as eco-friendly as metal or tile, as they contribute to landfill waste and require more frequent replacement.


Best For:

Homeowners looking for a classic, cost-effective, and reliable roofing option that balances durability and aesthetics.


Metal Roofing: Durable & Energy-Efficient


Metal roofing has gained popularity in Missouri due to its impressive longevity, energy efficiency, and ability to withstand severe weather conditions. While it is available in various styles (including standing seam panels and metal shingles), metal roofing has a distinct aesthetic appearance and a steep up-front cost.


Pros of Metal Roofing


Exceptional Durability – Metal roofs can last 40-70 years (20-40 years longer than shingle roofs), making them a long-term investment for homeowners.
Weather Resistance
  – Metal roofs hold up well against high winds, hail, and heavy rain, making them ideal for Missouri’s unpredictable climate.
Energy Efficiency
– Metal reflects sunlight, helping to keep homes cooler in the summer and reducing energy bills.
Eco-Friendly
  – Many metal roofs contain recycled materials and are 100% recyclable at the end of their lifespan.
Low Maintenance
– Unlike shingles, metal roofing requires minimal maintenance and is resistant to mold, mildew, and pests.


Cons of Metal Roofing


Higher Up-Front Cost – The initial investment for metal roofing is higher than asphalt shingles, though its longevity helps offset the cost over time.
Potential for Dents
– While metal roofs are highly durable, certain types (like aluminum or copper) can dent from large hail or falling branches.
Noise
  – Metal roofs can be noisier during heavy rain or hail, though proper insulation can minimize this issue.

Best For:

Homeowners who prioritize longevity, weather resistance, and energy efficiency over initial cost. Ideal for those planning to stay in their home for decades.


Tile Roofing: The Aesthetic & Long-Lasting Choice


Tile roofing is a premium roofing option typically made of clay or concrete. It offers unmatched durability and aesthetic appeal at a high price-point. This style of roofing is less common in Missouri than in warmer, dryer climates, but it can still be the right choice for some St. Louis homeowners.


Pros of Tile Roofing


Longevity – Tile roofs can last 50-100 years (even longer than metal roofs), making them one of the most durable roofing materials available.
Fire & Pest Resistant
  – Unlike wood or asphalt, tile is highly resistant to fire, insects, and rot.
Energy Efficiency
– Tile roofs provide natural insulation, keeping homes cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter.
Aesthetic Appeal
– Tile roofs offer a distinct, high-end look that enhances curb appeal and property value.


Cons of Tile Roofing


Expensive Up-Front Cost – Tile roofing is one of the most costly roofing materials in terms of both materials and labor.

Heavy Weight – Clay and concrete tiles are significantly heavier than shingles or metal, requiring additional structural support.
Fragility
– While highly durable, individual tiles can break if walked on or struck by heavy debris.

Best For:

Homeowners seeking a premium, long-lasting roofing option that enhances curb appeal and can withstand extreme weather. Ideal for high-end homes and those in historic districts.


The Best Roofing Material for Your Home


The best roofing material for your home depends on YOU. Typically the choice for a MO home is asphalt shingles, but if you’re a homeowner looking for something more distinct or long-lasting, metal or tile roofing might be for you.

Roofing Material Lifespan Cost Weather Resistance
ASPHALT SHINGLES 15-30 years Low Moderate
METAL ROOFING 40-70 years Medium-High High
TILE ROOFING 50-100 years High High
  • If you want an affordable and versatile option, asphalt shingles are a great choice.
  • If durability and energy efficiency are your priority, metal roofing is an excellent investment.
  • If you’re looking for longevity and luxury, tile roofing is the best but most expensive option.


Before making your final decision,
call us at (314) 350-7378. Our professional team at Big Bear Roofing can assess your home’s structure and particular needs. A quality roof is an investment that protects your home and enhances its value for years to come – let us help you make sure you’re choosing the right one!


Need expert advice on your next roofing project?
  Contact us today for a free consultation and find the perfect roofing solution for your Missouri home! 



You might also like

Spring Storms and Roof Damage: Signs You Need an Inspection

By Big Bear Roofing March 5, 2025
While it still feels like winter here in Missouri, Spring is just around the corner – and with it a new challenge for your roof – spring storms. Heavy rain, strong winds, hail, sleet, and even tornadoes can wreak havoc on your home (particularly your roof) during this season. Your roof is your home’s first line of defense against the elements so it is crucial to inspect it after a storm to catch potential damage early. At Big Bear Roofing , we know just how much storms can affect your home’s roof – and we know how important it is to act quickly when dealing with roof damage. After a storm, we will repair your roof quickly and have you back to feeling safe and secure in your home. How Spring Storms Impact Your Roof In Missouri, spring storms can be unpredictable and intense. It’s important to be prepared beforehand, but even preparedness doesn’t always stop unexpected debris and other hazards caused by extreme weather conditions. Common ways spring weather can damage your roof: 1. High Winds Storms often bring strong winds that can lift, loosen, or completely remove shingles. Beyond the direct damage that wind can cause your roof, it can also blow debris (like tree branches) onto your roof, causing punctures or cracks. Over time, missing shingles can expose the underlying structure of your home, leading to leaks and expensive structural damage. The most cost-effective option for Missouri homeowners is to fix these issues before they become major problems for your roof and your wallet. 2. Heavy Rain The consistent, heavy rainfall that often accompanies Missouri’s spring storms can wear down roofing materials (especially if your roof is more than ten years old). Additionally, if your gutters are clogged or damaged, water may pool on your roof, increasing the risk of leaks and water damage inside your home. 3. Hail Damage In the spring, hailstorms are common in Missouri and can cause significant damage. Hailstones dent metal roofing, crack shingles, and dislodge protective granules. Even small hail can weaken the integrity of your roof over time, making it more susceptible to future damage. All types of hail can cause seemingly small problems that lead to large, structural issues if left unrepaired. 4. Fallen Debris All Missouri homeowners know that our spring storms can break tree limbs and send all kinds of debris flying. This is bad news for your roof because all forms of debris can puncture or crack it, leading either to immediate problems or problems down the road. Even when the impact doesn’t seem severe, small holes and cracks can lead to bigger problems when they’re left unaddressed. 7 Signs You Need a Roof Inspection After a Storm As a homeowner, it’s essential to check your roof after a storm to assess the damage. While some issues are obvious (even to untrained eyes), sometimes you need to call in a professional. These are key signs that you need a professional roofing contractor to inspect your roof for damage. 1. Missing or Damaged Shingles Missing and damaged shingles are typically very easy to identify. If you notice shingles on the ground or see bald spots on your roof, high winds may have blown them off. Curled, cracked, or torn shingles can also indicate storm damage. 2. Water Stains on Ceilings or Walls Water stains (or discoloration with an unidentified cause) inside your home could mean a leaky roof. Even when the leak isn’t immediately visible, moisture intrusion can lead to mold growth and structural damage. 3. Granule Loss in Gutters Hail and heavy rain can strip shingles of their protective granules. These granules ensure the longevity of a shingle roof, so losing them can drastically lower the roof’s lifespan. Check your gutters and downspouts for an accumulation of granules—this could be a sign that your roof’s lifespan is decreasing. 4. Dented or Damaged Flashing Flashing around chimneys, vents, and skylights helps prevent water infiltration. If you see dents, cracks, or gaps in these areas, your roof may be vulnerable to leaks. 5. Sagging Roof or Soft Spots If parts of your roof appear to sag or feel soft when pressed, moisture may have compromised the underlying structure. This is a serious issue that requires immediate attention to prevent collapse. 6. Clogged or Damaged Gutters Gutters play a crucial role in directing water away from your home. If they are clogged, bent, or detached after a storm, water can back up onto your roof and cause leaks. 7. Visible Roof Debris If you find large tree limbs or other debris on your roof, it’s best to have a professional inspect for any punctures or hidden damage. While small punctures may be invisible to your eye, a professional can identify them before they become a major issue. If you see any of these signs, call Big Bear Roofing today! Our team will quickly assess the damage and fix any problems that storm damage has caused. What to Do if Your Roof is Damaged If you suspect roof damage after a storm, taking action quickly can save you money, time, and future stress by preventing further problems. Following these steps will help you protect your home and make sure your roof gets the repairs it needs. 1. Conduct a Visual Inspection After the storm passes, conduct a visual inspection from the ground. Look for obvious signs of damage (like missing shingles, sagging sections of the roof, or fallen debris). Avoid climbing onto the roof yourself as damaged areas may be unsafe. 2. Document the Damage Take clear photos and videos of any visible damage. This will be useful for insurance claims and when discussing repairs with a contractor. 3. Contact a Professional Roofing Contractor Schedule a free inspection with Big Bear Roofing . We will assess the extent of the damage, provide repair recommendations, and help prevent minor issues from becoming major problems. Preventative Measures for Future Storms While you can’t stop a storm from happening, you can take steps to minimize damage to your roof. With these tips, your home (and roof) will be well-prepared for any future storms. Trim Trees Regularly: Remove overhanging branches that could fall onto your roof during a storm. Clean Gutters and Downspouts: Ensure proper water drainage to prevent pooling and leaks. Schedule Routine Roof Inspections: A professional inspection at least once a year can catch potential problems before they worsen. Upgrade to Impact-Resistant Shingles: Impact-resistant shingles are designed to withstand hail and heavy winds, providing extra protection. Secure Loose Roofing Materials: Check flashing, vents, and gutters to make sure they are firmly attached. Contact Us Today Missouri storms can be hard on your roof, but with Big Bear Roofing you can quickly know the extent of the damage and have it repaired before it ever becomes a major issue. Contact us today for a free estimate! Call us at (314) 350-7378 or visit https://www.bigbearroofingstl.com/ to schedule your appointment.
A close up of a roof with a hole in it.
By Big Bear Roofing January 24, 2025
Discover the most common shingle roofing issues in St. Louis, MO, and how to fix them! Learn about roof leaks, curling shingles, granule loss, and more. Contact Big Bear Roofing for expert repairs and replacements today!
A person is using a machine to cut a piece of foam on a roof.
By Big Bear Roofing January 24, 2025
Learn the key differences between TPO and EPDM roofing systems in St. Louis, MO. Discover the benefits, costs, and best applications of each material to make an informed choice. Contact Big Bear Roofing for expert installation and tailored solutions!
More Posts

Book a Service Today

Share by: